Smile 2’s Naomi Scott and Parker Finn talk pop nightmares and horror dreams - INTO
Out of the Celluloid Closet

Smile 2’s Naomi Scott and Parker Finn talk pop nightmares and horror dreams

Smile 2 is writer and director Parker Finn’s sequel to the box office smash Smile, a film that made audiences never trust a smiling stranger again. The first film caused moviegoers to squirm as they endured psychological thrills paired with gruesome deaths. Now, Smile 2 continues to terrify audiences, one toothy grin at a time. 

Taking place shortly after the events of the first movie, fans are trapped in the orbit of pop star Skye Riley (Naomi Scott). With a new lease on life, a new album, and a world tour on the horizon after a traumatic experience, Skye picks up the pieces of her life in a classic pop manner. But everything starts to crumble when increasingly disturbing events cause Skye to question what’s reality outside of the nightmare she can’t seem to wake up from. 

INTO chatted with Finn and Scott to dish on which horror movies influenced Smile 2, uncover which entertainers Scott channeled to become Skye. and dive deeper into how sound turns pop dreams into nightmares. 

Naomi, I know how your character Skye Riley handles Miles Gutierrez-Riley’s “Joshua” in Smile 2. So, please don’t come for me. 

NAOMI SCOTT: Oh, my gosh (laughs). Yes! It was the most fun, by the way. I loved it. I love how throughout the movie, she barely ever looks at him, which is just my favorite thing.

You’re leading a horror film, but are you a horror movie fan?

I really, really did not grow up watching horror movies. It’s been a newer thing for me, and something that, honestly, I’m continuing to discover. I’m by no means an expert, but I genuinely have fallen in love with the genre. I do feel like some of the best movies ever made are horror. The Shining has to be up there, right? Just a masterpiece. And you think about The Shining and the original Suspiria, all the horror movies that also feel like the art direction is intrinsically linked to everything about those movies, [it’s] so inspiring for any creative person. But also, I think horror allows us to explore darker parts of humanity that are harder to talk about in other genres, and it allows you to take a swing and go for something. My favorite, though, is probably Don’t Look Now. Maybe that’s a weird one, but it’s so emotional, beautiful, and poetic, and it’s about grief, right? That’s what I love about horror movies, even the most high entertainment, jump scare, fun version of [them]. In terms of horror, it’s always exploring some dark [part] of humanity.

Speaking of horror fans, Parker, you wrote an essay for Variety recently where you stated that “The Shining is not only my favorite horror film — it’s quite possibly my favorite film of all time.” Are there any elements from that film appearing in Smile 2?

I mean, Kubrick is my favorite filmmaker. I think a lot of filmmakers, but myself personally, wear a lot of my influences on [their] sleeves, both in terms of craft, atmosphere, big performances, and things like that. I think that you can definitely look to The Shining for that sort of inspiration. But also, what I love about The Shining is that [it] is terrifying without hardly ever putting us into even a dark environment or anything like that. You know, it’s not about trying to hide things in the shadows. It’s about what’s bubbling up from inside these human beings. You know, it’s that little supernatural push that causes all this really human horror to happen, and I hope that [Smile 2] is infused with that as well.

Parker, Smile was an adaptation of your short film Laura Hasn’t Slept and Smile 2 is a continuation of this story/adaptation. We could’ve stopped with the first film; however, did you already have a sequel in mind?

I wanted Smile to tell its own complete, contained story, and I was just hoping it would find an audience. When it was clear that audiences were really embracing it, and there was an opportunity to potentially create a sequel, I wanted to make sure that I wasn’t just doing an obvious continuation or retread. If I was going to ask audiences to give me their time again, I was going to try to deliver something that was unexpected, fresh, and a really, exciting, new way in. And so it was the discovery of this character of Skye Riley, this mega pop star, that really unlocked everything for me. It felt like such a wonderfully opposite world from the first film that felt like a very cool challenge to explore.

Naomi, Skye is a pop star and you got to flex your stellar musical talents. Were there any pop stars you channeled to get into character?

Honestly, there was a lot about Skye that was already in motion, in terms of crafting who she was when I got there. Three of the songs were already written. Parker’s vision of Skye was already happening. So for me, I just wanted to step into those things that were already going on and see what organically happens. I didn’t really have a person in mind. There were three songs that were written, two of which were written and produced by Idarose, this incredible writer-producer, and her voice was on the demo. So I actually used her as the blueprint, in terms of leaning into figuring out Skye’s voice, because that’s not me singing on these songs. It really is Skye, and I don’t sound like myself in a way, which is what I wanted. 

I think horror allows us to explore darker parts of humanity that are harder to talk about in other genres, and it allows you to take a swing and go for something.

Naomi Scott

I didn’t want it to be too derivative of a specific thing. But of course, all of those references and those things that I’ve watched growing up and watched recently, it’s all in there probably somewhere. But I wanted it to be like, “What’s something new that could happen with all of these things that have already been crafted for Skye?” and then me stepping into those shoes.

Parker, there’s such an emphasis on sound and music in Smile 2, like Skye’s pop hits, that really elevates this atmospheric horror and puts the audience in Skye’s position of not knowing what’s real and what isn’t. What was the process to get that just right?

It’s all about using all the tools of filmmaking. And so again, we enter into this world that should be shiny, glammy, and glitzy and, you know, just an utter delight. I didn’t want to shy away from that. I didn’t want this film to be set in dark basements or spider-filled attics or anything like that. I wanted to really be true to the world, but could I take that world and make it menacing and make it dripping with anxiety, dread, stress, and fright. So, it’s all about  how we subjectively tie ourselves to the character. I wanted to put the audience in Skye’s shoes, as she’s spiraling out of control, as we’re all feeling everything she’s feeling, and that the film is sort of, surprising [her], tricking her, and gaslighting her. It’s doing the exact same thing to the audience, especially an audience that thinks they’re coming in hip to things because they’ve seen the first one. I wanted to see if I could maybe use that against them and find brand new ways to terrify them and stress them out.♦

Smile 2 is in theaters now. 

Sign up for the INTO newsletter and get your twice-weekly dose of stories that shape the queer experience, culture, and lifestyle.