The internet works in mysterious ways sometimes, and Twitter trends are no exception.
Seemingly out of nowhere, the hashtag “#CisWithTheT” started trending in the United Kingdom and elsewhere today, with many people — but mostly cis white women — declaring they are comfortable with trans women in women’s spaces and beyond.
https://twitter.com/prince_catboy/status/1453409566637625348
It may seem like the hashtag came up randomly, but it follows a visceral amount of transphobia in media and public discourse over recent days. Besides the ongoing controversies surrounding Dave Chappelle, trans youth in sports, and the usual-but-still-ridiculous “pronouns are stupid” declarations, a BBC story was published this week with the title, ‘We’re being pressured into sex by some trans women’.
The story cites a study by “Get the L Out,” an anti-trans organization, purportedly reflecting the perspective of several lesbians who claim that they are being targeted for being anti-trans or not wanting trans women in cis women spaces.
As the title of the article suggests, several claim they and others have experienced “pressure” (as is used several times in the story) from trans women to accept having sex with them. One person is reported as saying that people “would rather kill me than Hitler” and even tweets and quotes included by other trans people that support lesbians’ efforts to exclude trans women.
Yesterday, another @BBC article unleashed a further wave of transphobic hate on the community. In response, #CisWithTheT is trending today. You as well can show solidarity to the trans community by posting a msg under the hashtag
— ILGA-Europe (@ILGAEurope) October 27, 2021
Despite the backlash, of course, the BBC has stood by their story in a statement and asserts that it is editorially sound, even though if you accept their own story’s reporting on its face, the so-called “pressure” being experienced by cis women is only from “a minority of trans women.”
Still, the report only encourages TERFs and anti-trans advocates, such as the LGB Alliance, who is even quoted in the BBC report as being “particularly concerned about younger and therefore more vulnerable lesbians.” With their scaremongering being furthered, the anti-trans group has tried to assert that the Twitter hashtag is an attempt to “silence” TERFs and cis women and lesbians.
Some have even pushed “#IStandWithLesbians” as a retort and claim that the hashtag attacks those who have been raped, although only one such allegation is reported by the BBC and is not the focus of the article or subsequent tweets.
Your internet debrief
Stay ahead of the most scandalous, hilarious, and mind-boggling internet content delivered directly to your inbox.
Yet, much of #CisWithTheT is cis women speaking up for themselves, seemingly unfettered.
I am a cis woman and I want to shout that trans women are women. I will always welcome you here. 💜 #CisWithTheT pic.twitter.com/KL5YDXsPCN
— Emily♡ (@ItsEmilyKaty) October 27, 2021
https://twitter.com/SMichaelsonn/status/1453306818566963217
https://twitter.com/AngryBlackLady/status/1453414658627440640
https://twitter.com/SpillerOfTea/status/1453291039163396103
https://twitter.com/KateHeywood8/status/1453304365465444362
Several other people spoke up too, on behalf of trans women and others in the community.
https://twitter.com/RainofTerra/status/1453455156729630720
Trans Woman here, its probably obvious that the BBC article turned my world upside down. Life atm is incredibly hard for us & yesterday really didn't help! I went to bed feeling lost & alone,
Waking up today to see all the love & support from #CisWithTheT really helped! Ty ❤
— Elle (@LieFE_of_Riley) October 27, 2021
I’m a cishet woman and I’m genuinely terrified of the GCs who try to reduce my womanhood to just my genitals and organs. I’ve been questioned in a toilet once because I’m tall, broad shouldered and dress tomboyish. GC ideology is a threat to all people #CisWithTheT https://t.co/HiYX25x7k4
— Jessica (@hotmessica__) October 27, 2021
TBH #IStandWithLesbians too – because all the queer, cis women I know agree that trans women are women and thought that the BBC News article was badly researched and massively offensive. #CisWithTheT
— Marc Burrows (@20thcenturymarc) October 27, 2021
It’s alarmingly obvious what’s going on 😡 …
The 80s vs Now: New baseless arguments, same bigotry. #CisWithTheT pic.twitter.com/AowElJIIu9
— James barr (@jamesbarrcomedy) October 27, 2021
Trans people are being monstered exactly as gay and bisexual people always were – as would-be sexual predators, recruiters of children, defiers of biological reality, sufferers of a mental condition, creepy fetishists, and so on.
Stand by our trans siblings 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️#CisWithTheT
— Owen Jones (@owenjonesjourno) October 27, 2021
Others made a point to note that while making tweets in support of trans women is fine and dandy, there is much more that needs to be done to protect trans and gender non-conforming people, especially as a litany of anti-trans laws here in the United States continue to take effect and anti-trans rhetoric continues to find a home in mainstream media outlets.
https://twitter.com/PrincessArylin/status/1453381375881617410
https://twitter.com/brynismyname/status/1453303821212524545
https://twitter.com/DavidPaisley/status/1453299013483171844
Thankfully, while some responses may be performative, many others are committing themselves to supporting trans people beyond typing on their keyboards.
I was hesitant to QT this as it might seem performative.
But being accused of performativeness is better than thinking silence is disagreement.
So yeah, I wholeheartedly support trans inclusion in women's spaces & would 100% Go Off at anyone I saw trying to exclude#CisWithTheT https://t.co/9szTd7IxJh
— Leanne🌱🍉 (@LeanneWain) October 27, 2021
I am a cis woman begging transphobes to stop tweeting because every time they do I have to donate to @Mermaids_Gender and honestly it's breaking the bank #CisWithTheT https://t.co/52kYtw9eD7
— Lou Del Bello (@LouDelBello) October 27, 2021
https://twitter.com/Bronwen85/status/1453339812820303876
https://twitter.com/VKirbyYork/status/1453368258216828937